Cookies That are Better than Crumbl Cookies in Nashville

No shade to the cookie giant (we all love a good frosted cookie!), but if you’re looking for the best cookies in Nashville, skip the chains and support local! Whether you’re visiting Music City or live here full time, here are some local cookies that are better than Crumbl Cookies in Nashville!

HiFi – for cookie lovers in East Nashville (the Donelson location has limited hours, so check before you go!), these music themed cookies rotate regularly, and I’ve yet to have a bad one!

Pink Door – they share a common color with Crumbl, as well as frosting and sprinkles. But, these are made fresh right here in Nashville. It’s the perfect neighborhood cookie store in Sylvan Park.

Doug and Dolly’s Cookies – Craving a classic-style cookie in Nashville? These more traditional bakes are a MUST try. The chocolate cherry cookie may have changed my life. Located in Donelson, and run by a couple with a great back story.

The Buttermilk Ranch – if you don’t want to wait for a table at the ever-popular Buttermilk Ranch, their counter service is walk-up. While their pastries rotate so I can’t GUARANTEE cookies, everything in their cases are perfection. So, you’ll win either way. In 12 South.

Sunflower Bakehouse – If you’re searching for gluten-free or vegan cookies in Nashville, Sunflower Bakehouse in Donelson is the place. Their GF kitchen does NOT sacrifice taste – and while you’re there, grab a cupcake parfait. They’re irresistible.